Most products on Modern Castle have a unique and customized testing and scoring process. You can read about those specific testing and scoring systems here. For products that fall outside of our core testing categories we use the following general testing and scoring process.
We test and score products using a battery of 5 data-driven tests. Our tests are a mix of objective testing and subjective assessment. This testing process applies to all other products without more dedicated testing processes.
Our 5 testing and scoring categories include:
- Performance
- Quality
- Design
- Value
- Usability
Performance
Scoring Weight – 20%
Our performance test is a subjective test. We use the product and measure how well it performs its designated purpose.
Quality
Scoring Weight – 20%
Our build quality test is a subjective test. We examine and assess the major material and design components of the product, rating the build quality of each element.
Specifically, we are looking for build and design issues that are more likely to break and/or be difficult to use.
Design
Score Weight – 20%
Our design test is a subjective test. We consider the overall design of the product. We consider how the design of the products improves the user experience or enhances the product.
Value
Score Weight – 20%
Our value test is a subjective test. We consider the qualities the product has to offer in relation to other similar products on the market, both in relation to price. In addition, we consider how much value the product brings to a user who needs this type of product.
Usability Test
Score Weight – 5%
Our usability test is a subjective test. We use the product and take note of any features, design choices, or enhancements made that improve the user experience.
