This comparison is going to look at iLife vs. Roomba. Both of these vacuums are strong contenders and offer quality cleans, but have a few key differences.
While iLife takes more of a budget approach, Roomba brings more technology and features to the table.
Which is the better robot?
iLife vs. Roomba
While both vacuums offer solid cleaning performance, scheduled cleanings, and other features, the Roomba 690 performed better on carpet and had more bells-and-whistles like wifi connectivity and virtual wall barriers for enhanced navigation. Overall, we feel the Roomba 690 simply offers more than the iLife A4s robot vacuum.Check PriceThis vacuum review is going to dive into each of these robots, assessing everything from cleaning performance, features, and accessories to size, noise, value, and more.
Which vacuum will take the crown?
Keep reading this vacuum review to find out in today’s showdown of iLife vs. Roomba.
iLife Review
The iLife A4s robot vacuum is a budget-friendly robot vacuum that is designed for up to 140 minutes of cleaning power. This robot vacuum also comes with a remote control for maintaining cleaning cycles and scheduling. T
The iLife’s round shape makes for easy maneuverability, and its spinning side brushes help to capture dirt and debris from edges and corners.
Pros
- There are several cleaning modes available.
- It’s a more budget-friendly option.
Cons
- Struggles on high pile carpets.
- There is no wifi connectivity available.
Bottom Line
The iLife A4s is a simple robot that lacks bells and whistles, but comes in at a good price. In addition, the “MAX” power mode is a nice feature for deeper carpet cleanings. Bonuses like this are not commonly found on less expensive models like this.
Roomba Review
The Roomba 690 is iRobot’s top of the line model within their Roomba 600 series. Roomba’s 600 series is more affordable. This robot vacuum has an easy to use “CLEAN” button as well as wifi connectivity.
It uses a central brushroll and spinning side brush to perform a cleaning cycle. In addition, a HEPA filter helps ensure file particles are captured for disposal.
Pros
- Can be controlled via your smartphone.
- Dirt detection helps find and eliminate debris.
Cons
- The 13″ diameter makes it a bit wider.
- Has longer cleaning cycles.
Bottom Line
The Roomba 690 provides a nice clean, but lacks the fancy bells and whistles of newer Roombas. That being said, the 690 offers excellent cleaning performance per dollar and the lowest cost to maintain we’ve tested to date.
iLife Design
The iLife A4s takes on a sleek and simple look; using a soft gray for the body and a thin chrome accent to highlight the on / off button. A darker gray forms the edge of this vacuum and wraps the front with a soft bumper to protect the vacuum as well as your furniture.
- On / Off button
- Bumper
There is a remote control that comes with this robot vacuum that has additional settings and preferences.
Roomba Design
The design of the Roomba 690 is also modern and simple. It uses a light gray and black for the body with bright green to highlight special features– such as the handle and dust bin release.
You can start a cycle with the “CLEAN” button directly on the vacuum.
- On / Off Clean
- Handle
- Bumper
- Dust bin release
For wireless control, you could also use the remote control or wifi connectivity for enhanced usability.
How iLife Cleans
The iLife A4s cleans using one of five different cleaning styles pre-programmed into the vacuum. These modes include mini-room, edge, spot, scheduled, and auto.
Regardless of the cleaning style, the iLife is programmed to clean using a three-stage process: SWEEP the edges using the spinning brushes, ROLL the dirt and debris with the central brushroll, and SUCK it all up.
- Wheels
- Spinning brushes
- Charging pins
- Brushroll
- Dust bin release
When running a cleaning cycle, you can either manually select the cleaning style or put it on auto, through which the iLife will decide for itself what cleaning cycle is best for the space.
How Roomba Cleans
A combination of rolling debris extractor brush, spinning brushes, and central suction come together as the Roomba 690’s core cleaning technology. Roomba uses dirt detection technology to spot clean heavy traffic areas.
Any other cleaning cycle is completed by Roomba automatically adjusting, with pre-programmed cleaning modes.
- Wheels
- Spinning brush
- Charging pins
- Brushroll
- Dust bin release
Roomba’s cleaning process is nearly identical to that of the iLife, using the side sweeping brush, the central brushroll, and the vacuum suction. To navigate, Roomba uses infrared light to sense space and detect obstacles.
iLife Size
The iLife A4s robot vacuum is a bit on the smaller size at only 12″ in diameter with a 3″ max height. This makes it a little easier to squeeze under tight furniture or around difficult obstacles.
- Diameter – 12″
- Height – 3″
Roomba Size
The Roomba 690 is a bit taller than the iLife, at 3.6″ tall (compared to 3″). Additionally, it’s a bit wider at 13″. The slightly larger size could prevent it from squeezing under certain obstacles within your home.
- Diameter – 13″
- Height – 3.6″
iLife Accessories & Parts
The iLife A4s comes with the following parts and accessories:
- Charging base – When low battery, the iLife will return to the charger.
- Remote control – Allows remote control of cleaning settings and preferences.
- (4) Spinning brushes – Sweeps dirt and debris from edges and corners into the main cleaning path.
- Cleaning tool – Used to maintain the vacuum and prevent dust or particle build-up.
- (2) HEPA filters – Helps trap fine particles and allergens.
Regarding accessories, the iLife A4s comes with everything you need to get going and a few replacement parts. The iLife does not include any virtual barriers.
Roomba Accessories & Parts
The Roomba 690 comes with the following parts and accessories:
- Virtual wall barrier – Block Roomba from cleaning areas in your home by using an infrared light beam, invisible to the naked eye, but detectable to Roomba.
- Charging base –When the Roomba is below 15%, it returns to the charging base automatically.
- HEPA filter – This is an internal filter that captures ultra-fine particulates.
- Cleaning tool – You can use this to clean the fine nooks and crannies of the Roomba.
The inclusion of the virtual wall barrier is a nice addition to the Roomba 690 package, making it easier for Roomba to navigate difficult spaces or contain Roomba in a single room without doors.
Cleaning Tests
The following vacuum cleaner tests are designed to show how the iRobot Roomba 690 robot vacuum cleaner performs on different surfaces, picking up a variety of debris types.
We test on three different floor types, including hardwood floors, low pile carpet, and high pile carpet. For each floor type, we test the vacuum cleaner against:
- Rice – 3 ounces
- Dry Cereal – 1 ounce
- Kitty Litter – 3 ounces
- Sugar – 3 ounces
iLife Hardwood Floor Tests
The iLife A4s did an excellent job cleaning debris off of the hardwood floor. It picked up nearly all of the debris, only leaving 1% of rice and 6% of sugar on the testing field.
See before and after test images.
Cereal
100%
Kitty Litter
100%
Rice
99%
Sugar
94%
iLife Low Pile Carpet Tests
As we moved onto the low carpet, the iLife started to struggle a little more. It had the most trouble with the sugar test, where it left 40% of the sugar on the floor.
See before and after test images.
Cereal
100%
Kitty Litter
90%
Rice
100%
Sugar
60%
iLife High Pile Carpet Tests
Similar to the low carpet, the high carpet tests showed the same issues with the iLife. Larger debris like rice and cereal were not a problem, while the kitty litter and sugar tests showed signs of a struggle.
See before and after test images.
Cereal
100%
Kitty Litter
85%
Rice
100%
Sugar
49%
Roomba Hardwood Floor Tests
The Roomba 690 did a fantastic job of cleaning on the hardwood floors, capturing at least 95% of the debris for each test type.
See before and after test images.
Cereal
100%
Kitty Litter
96%
Rice
99%
Sugar
95%
Roomba Low Pile Carpet Tests
Similar to iLife, the low pile carpet test began to show some signs of struggle with the fine debris types, capturing only 72% of sugar. The other debris tests were excellent.
See before and after test images.
Cereal
100%
Kitty Litter
98%
Rice
100%
Sugar
72%
Roomba High Pile Carpet Tests
Like the low carpet, the Roomba high carpet tests showed signs of struggle with the sugar, capturing only 66% of debris. Rice, cereal, and kitty litter were not a problem (99% captured).
See before and after test images.
Cereal
99%
Kitty Litter
99%
Rice
99%
Sugar
66%
iLife Usability
Setting up the iLife robot vacuum was incredibly easy. Just unbox the vacuum, snap on the spinning brushes, remove the foam pads from the bumper wall, charge it, and let it go.
If you decide to use the remote, simply add the AA batteries and you’re set. Run on auto for the easiest usability.
Roomba Usability
Setting up the Roomba was also virtually pain free. Similar to iLife, unbox, install the spinning brushes, charge it up, and you’re ready to clean.
Starting a new cycle is as easy as pressing the large “CLEAN” button or you can schedule cleaning cycles. Setting up the app took only two minutes and I was ready to clean.
iLife Maneuverability
The iLife A4s is incredibly light and it’s smaller body style makes it easier to squeeze into tight corners or next to furniture.
- Weight – 4.9 pounds
- Width – 12″
- Height – 3″
- Turning – 360 degree
Similar to other round robots, the circular shape of this vacuum really helps it to maneuver within the space effectively.
Roomba Maneuverability
The maneuverability of the Roomba 690 is quite good, with its round body style and navigation technology.
- Weight – 7.8 pounds
- Width – 13″
- Height – 3.6″
- Turning – 360 degree
Additional features like Roomba’s dirt detection and drop detection makes it easier for the vacuum to navigate difficult areas without getting stuck or falling from stairs or lofted spaces.
iLife Maintenance
There are limited parts on the iLife A4s that require special maintenance, and the parts that do require maintenance are generally affordable. To prolong the filter life, be sure to wash it after every 15-30 days, depending on use.
Accessory / Part | Replacement Frequency | Replacement Cost |
---|---|---|
HEPA Filter | 6 months | Check Price |
Brushroll | 12 months | Check Price |
Spinning brush | 6 months | Check Price |
Battery | 12-24 months | Check Price |
The maintenance for the iLife A4s is relatively easy and the low cost of the battery is a nice bonus. Both the iLife and Roomba have 6 month battery warranties.
The cost to maintain the unit is around $44 / year.
Roomba Maintenance
Maintenance on the Roomba 690 is painless and inexpensive. The HEPA filter needs to be replaced every 2 months, spinning brushes every 6 months, and the brushroll every 1-2 years.
Accessory / Part | Replacement Frequency | Replacement Cost |
---|---|---|
Filter | 2 months | Check Price |
Spinning brush | 6 months | Check Price |
Front wheel | 12 months | Check Price |
Brushroll | 12 months | Check Price |
Battery | 18-36 months | Check Price |
Due to their popularity, replacement parts for Roomba’s tend to be more widely available and less expensive, compared to other robot vacuums.
The cost to maintain the unit is around $32 / year.
iLife Battery
The iLife battery is 2,600 mAh and takes 3-4 hours to generate a full charge. With a full charge, you can expect to run your vacuum 120-140 minutes.
Battery | Details |
---|---|
Size | 2,600 mAh |
Charging Time | 3-4 hours |
Run Time | 120-140 minutes |
Replacement Cost | Check Price |
I must admit, this estimated run time by the manufacturer feels a little long, compared to other comparable vacuums (which usually run about 60 minutes).
In addition, this battery only has 2,600 mAh, but with its lighter weight, it is possible that it doesn’t take as much battery to move around the space.
Roomba Battery
The Roomba battery has a notably larger capacity compared to the iLife, at 3,000 mAh. Additionally, it’s quicker to charge at 2 hours.
Battery | Details |
---|---|
Size | 1,800 mAh |
Charging Time | 2-3 hours |
Run Time | 90 minutes |
Replacement Cost | Check Price |
Based on manufacturer’s claims, the iLife has a longer battery life for cleaning cycles (120 minutes vs. 60 minutes), but the Roomba has a quicker charge time.
iLife Noise
All vacuum cleaner reviews on Modern Castle are put through our standard noise test. For this test, we use a sound meter to measure noise in terms of decibel level approximately 3′ away from the vacuum.
Compared to the Roomba 690, the iLife A4s was noticeably quieter.
At 3′ away, the iLife A4s robot vacuum emits 54 dB of sound.
Roomba Noise
All vacuum cleaner reviews on Modern Castle are put through our standard noise test. For this test, we use a sound meter to measure noise in terms of decibel level approximately 3′ away from the vacuum.
Compared to the iLife A4s, the Roomba 690 was noticeably louder.
At 3′ away, the Roomba 690 robot vacuum emits 68 dB of sound.
iLife Value
The iLife A4s robot vacuum is budget-priced, so it’s a bit less expensive than the Roomba 690,and for what you get, it still maintains a solid value.
On hardwoods, the cleaning performance was excellent and really only dropped when it moved to carpeted floors or when it was trying to capture fine debris.
For people who mainly only clear hard floors, the drop in carpeted performance may not even be an issue. Even so, the only significant cleaning performance issue remained ultra fine particles on carpets.
- Warranty – 1 year
- Returns – 30 days
- Company – Great
- Value – Great
The remote control was also a nice add, especially considering the lower price point. Its lack of wifi connectivity or virtual barriers was a little disappointing, but again, not unexpected due to the low price.
Roomba Value
The Roomba 690 is an excellent value, in my opinion. It lacks some of the fancier bells and whistles of newer Roomba models but compared to similarly priced robot vacuums, it really shines.
Beyond just cleaning performance, the addition of the virtual wall barrier and wifi connectivity are both big bonuses for the Roomba.
In addition, the low maintenance costs are an added bonus, averaging about $12 less per year over the iLife.
- Warranty – 1 year
- Returns – 30 days
- Company – Great
- Value – Great
During the company analysis, we did not find any major red flags or questionable business practices. iRobot also offers a 1 year warranty and 30-day return policy, via Amazon.
iLife Specifications
Specifications | |
---|---|
Type | Robot |
Manufacturer | iLife |
Model | A4s |
Length (inches) | 12 |
Width (inches) | 12 |
Height (inches) | 3 |
Weight (pounds) | 4.9 |
Floor Type | All (indoor) |
Battery | 2,600 mAh |
Dust Bin Capacity | 0.4 L |
Cordless | Yes |
Bagless | Yes |
Returns | Varies by retailer |
Warranty | 1-Year limited |
Price | Check Price |
Roomba Specifications
Specifications | |
---|---|
Type | Robot |
Manufacturer | iRobot |
Model | Roomba 690 |
Length | 13" |
Width | 13" |
Height | 3.6" |
Weight | 7.8 lbs |
Floor Type | All (indoor) |
Battery | 1,800 mAh |
Dust Bin Capacity | 0.3 liter |
Cordless | Yes |
Bagless | Yes |
Returns | Varies by retailer |
Warranty | 1-Year limited |
Price | Check Price |
iLife vs. Roomba, Which Should You Buy?
So iLife vs. Roomba, who is the winner? This vacuum battle was a tough one, mainly because the price points of each of these vacuums was such a jump. Both iLife and Roomba have some great features, but overall we feel the Roomba is the better choice compared to the iLife.
Additional accessories, better cleaning performance, smartphone control, lower replacement part costs, and a larger capacity battery are a few of the major advantages of the Roomba vs. iLife.
That said, the iLife is still a great choice. The iLife has a smaller body dimension, slimmer height, is quieter, and had excellent cleaning performance on almost all debris types, only struggling with sugar on carpets.
Which is the better robot?
Winner: Roomba 690
Is the iLife A4s a poor quality vacuum? Absolutely not, but compared to the performance and features of the Roomba 690, it’s just hard to beat. If you’ve got the money, the added value that Roomba provides makes it a true investment in a quality product.Check PriceWinner by Category
Category | Winner? | Explanation |
---|---|---|
Accessories | Roomba | Roomba including the virtual wall barrier was a nice addition to help with navigation. iLife lacked this accessory, and while the remote control was a cool feature, it couldn't really compete with Roomba's smartphone connectivity. |
Cleaning | Roomba | Roomba was comparable or outperformed the iLife on all cleaning tests. The difference was most significant on low and high pile carpets, especially for sugar. |
Usability | Roomba | Both vacuums were easy to use. The Roomba edged out iLife here, simply due to the wifi connectivity, a nice feature that the iLife just didn't have. |
Maintenance | Roomba | Roomba's annual cost to maintain is around $32, whereas the iLife is around $44. While not a huge difference, again, Roomba takes the price for maintenance too. |
Battery | iLife | iLife is able to run considerably longer than the Roomba 690 |
Noise | iLife | iLife was noticeably less noisy at 54 decibels compared to the Roomba 690’s 68 decibels. |
Value | Draw | Value was a tie for this comparison. While Roomba clearly offers better performance and has more accessories, the iLife is notably cheaper. |
Should You Buy the iLife?
The iLife A4s is a smaller vacuum and had good cleaning performance. In addition, the remote control was a nice feature for better cleanings.
Compared to other vacuums, the maintenance costs may also be considerably lower, but compared to Roomba it was slightly higher ($44 / year vs. $32 / year).
You Should Buy If…
- You want a lower price – Priced within the budget-tier ($), the iLife A4s is a great deal and offers solid cleaning performance across the board.
- You want a slimmer profile – Overall, the iLife is 1″ narrower all the way around compared to the Roomba, and it’s also 0.6″ shorter, meaning better maneuverability in some cases, especially if you have low furniture.
- You want a quieter robot vacuum – At 3′ away, the iLife A4s was 14 decibels quieter than the Roomba 690 model.
For more information or to buy, check out the iLife A4s on Amazon.com.
Should You Buy the Roomba?
The Roomba 690 is an excellent value. Overall, it simply offers more than the iLife A4s with better cleaning performance, wifi connectivity, a larger capacity battery, and lower maintenance costs.
It costs notably more, but the added features and lower annual maintenance costs will quickly make up the gap, in our opinion.
You Should Buy If…
- You want lower maintenance costs – The Roomba has the lowest annual maintenance costs of any robot vacuum we have tested to date.
- You want better cleaning performance on carpet – While hardwoods test results were comparable, the carpet tests really showed the difference in cleaning power. The Roomba 690 was notably better on low and high pile carpets compared to the iLife.
- You want wifi connectivity– The iLife offers a remote control, but it’s hard to beat the usability of an app on your smartphone, which Roomba provides.
For more information or to buy, check out the Roomba 690 here.