Select Page

Nest Thermostat Review

Updated September 5, 2018 by Derek Hales

Nest Thermostat review

Overall Score: 95%
Design: 97%
Performance: 95%
Quality: 95%
Usability: 95%
Value: 95%
See how we score here.

Nest 3rd Generation

The Bottom Line

The Nest Learning Thermostat is currently on the 3rd generation model and comes with many top-of-the-line features, like wifi connectivity, on-board sensors (including temperature, humidity, motion, proximity, and ambient light). It is also compatible with voice control, but a voice control unit is not built-in. The Nest is easy to use, quick to install, equipped with great features, and a great way to help save money on your energy bills.

Pros

  • Great user interface makes this model easy to install and use on a daily basis
  • Easy setting control directly with your smartphone or use on-board sensors to “learn” about your life and automatically update settings

Cons

  • More expensive than traditional programmable thermostat units
  • Lacks touchscreen controls like its competitor, Ecobee.
Home » Best Smart Home Devices » Nest Thermostat Review

We are supported by readers purchasing products we feature. When you buy products with our links, we earn a commission. Questions? See how Modern Castle works.

Nest Learning Thermostat Design

The Nest Learning Thermostat is a smart thermostat with all of the best features, including advanced sensors, programmable settings, and a user interface that mimics the look of Apple or Google simplicity.

First, let’s talk display:

The central display is 2.08″ in diameter and in full color. The display isn’t touchscreen, but instead has the familiar feel of a round thermostat with adjustment knob. Using the rotating wheel, you can select different features, settings, and adjust the desired temperature.

Nest depth off of the wall

Nest installed in my home

What can Nest do?

There are a wide variety of features that come with the Nest Learning Thermostat to help improve the user experience and energy efficiency.

Smart features of the Next Learning Thermostat include:

  1. EarlyOn: This feature can turn on your Nest thermostat earlier than usual if the temperature outside is chilly.
  2. Off Mode: If you’re taking a road trip or going on vacation, Off Mode can be a nice tool. When in “Off Mode” the thermostat conserves a high amount of energy by running at the lowest possible setting, without turning completely off. That means no freezing pipes in the winter, but also no outrageously high energy bills for time you didn’t spend at home.
  3. Sunblock: The Sunblock feature has the ability to detect when a sensor is in direct sunlight and adjust accordingly in order to obtain the desired room temperature that you’re looking for.
  4. FarSight: FarSight is a technology that is pretty unique to the Nest smart thermostat. FarSight is an occupant detection sensor that senses when you’re approaching the unit and when you’re far way. When looking at it from far away, the units are larger and have a simpler design.

FarSight display screen - Nest Learning Thermostat

RELATED – Ready to go big on smart home? See our full Smart home device review series.

Size & Dimensions

The size of the Nest Learning Thermostat is slightly smaller than competitively priced, ecobee.

How big is Nest?

The Nest is 3.3″ in diameter while the ecobee models are rounded off squares ranging from 3.9-4.3″ in length and width. The Nest sticks out from the wall a little more than the ecobee—1.2″ vs. 1.0″ on the ecobee4.

Nest thermostat size

The Nest Thermostat has a diameter of 3.3″ and a thickness of 1.2″

Overall Dimensions:

  • 3.3″ diameter
  • 1.2″ depth

Want to know more? 

Click here to see a full head-to-had match up of ecobee vs. Nest to see which is the best smart thermostat out there.

Ecobee vs. Nest thermostat

Optional Accessories

The Nest Learning Thermostat doesn’t really come with a wide range of accessories for the Nest. That being said, there are a few quick add-ons that can help to provide a better user experience.

TEMPERATURE SENSOR | The Nest Temperature sensor works similarly to the ecobee room sensor. Simply place the sensor in the room that you would like to monitor and let it do its thing. The sensor will communicate directly with your Nest thermostat and ensure that that room stays the perfect temperature.

SMOKE & CARBON MONOXIDE ALARM | While not really an accessory for the thermostat itself, this seems like an appropriate place to mentioned the Smoke & Carbon Monoxide Alarm. This accessory can be used in conjunction with your smart thermostat for full protection and air quality comfort.

VOICE CONTROL HUB | The Nest Learning Thermostat is compatible with voice-control units, but doesn’t have this already built-in, like on the ecobee4 smart thermostat. But with the purchase of a voice control hub, like Amazon Echo or Google Home, you can easily add your Nest thermostat and control with a simple voice command.

Performance

The performance of the Nest Learning Thermostat comes down to one thing really—energy efficiency.

Nest Thermostat back view of control panel and wiring

Back view of the Nest thermostat

If a smart thermostat cannot successfully reduce energy costs, while keeping your home comfortable, it is really not checking all the boxes of a smart HVAC system.

You’re wondering how Nest saves money?

Here are a couple features that the Nest smart thermostat includes, which help to ensure energy savings across the board:

  1.  Auto-Away – The Nest smart thermostat detects when you leave your house and adjusts energy settings accordingly. Pay for energy you use when you’re home, save energy when you’re not.
  2. Auto Schedule – The auto-schedule feature is the software in the unit that automatically learns the temperature you like at certain times of the day. All you need to do is set it to a temperature that is comfortable at various times of the day and the Nest will remember and default to those settings.
  3. Airwave – Airwave is great for energy savings. This technology is designed to help relieve the system when it reaches the desired temperature, by turning on the fan and circulating the air around the space, without using additional energy.
  4. Alerts & Reminders – Safety alerts and reminders help to keep your Nest thermostat running smoothly by sending you a notification if something goes awry in your system, like unusually high or low temperatures.
  5. Energy History Reports – Lastly, the Nest app offers complete energy history reports that show you an overview of energy usage throughout the month. This report can be used to cross-check previous months and identify ways that you could be saving energy (and money) throughout the month.
Nest Thermostat energy history usage

Nest Thermostat energy history usage

Usability

Next, unboxing and installing:

Arguably the hardest part of setting up your smart thermostat is the initial install. Because let’s face it, if you’re not a certified electrician or HVAC specialist, the thought it getting behind the wall of your thermostat is more than a little daunting.

The appeal of smart thermostats, like Nest or ecobee (full Nest vs. Ecobee comparison here), is that they are extremely easy to install and operate.

RELATED – A smart home hub can help more seamlessly integrate your thermostat into the rest of your home. Read the SmartThings vs. Wink smart hub comparison here.

It doesn’t take an expert or a specialist, just a regular person with a the Nest user guide—that’s it. The user guide and app combined use a lot of helpful graphics, color-coded highlights, and simple diagrams to make install quick and painless.

Nest Smart Thermostat wiring configuration and setup

By comparison…

If you’re looking at the Nest Thermostat E, the install and setup is ever easier.

Nest Thermostat E

Nest Thermostat E

The Nest E is not compatible with all systems (probably one of the biggest “cons” of the E thermostat), but the result is an extremely simple system that is a breeze to install.

Nest Thermostat E setup and install

Nest Thermostat E setup and install

How’s the day-to-day usage?

The daily use of the Nest Learning Thermostat is as simple or as complex as you want it to be. Many of these features can be controlled individually or through programmed pre-sets.

Nest smartphone app control

The user interface on the Nest smartphone app

The concept behind the Nest Learning Thermostat is that it does just that—it learns. As you live your life, it starts to teach itself about your preferred settings, temperature, and schedule.

Nest thermostat scheduling

You can easily program the Nest to follow a precise day-by-day, hour-by-hour schedule

But how?

To keep you in the loop, smartphone connection and in-home FarSight visual display helps to make sure that you always know what your smart thermostat is up and how it’s using energy. Monthly energy reports are available to see how your energy saving goals are stacking up against overall usage.

Nest Smart Thermostat on Eco Mode

Nest Eco-mode can automatically adjust itself, saving you money

Any disadvantages?

Perhaps the biggest disadvantage is its incompatibility with the Samsung Smartthings Hub, which we recently tested and reviewed here. I’ve been really impressed with both SmartThings and Nest, so it’s a hard choice to make.

Lastly, sort of a minor disadvantage — the absence of built in voice control.

However, it should be noted you can add a standalone voice control unit and that will work fine. But it doesn’t have it built in like the ecobee4 does. Again, it’s minor, but it’s something.

Is the Nest Learning Thermostat a Good Value?

Nest Learning Thermostat smart thermostatSo that’s the run down on the Nest Learning Thermostat review.

Big question remaining—do the features listed above equate to a good product value overall? In my opinion, the answer would be yes.

If comparing the Nest to a traditional programmable thermostat, the difference in price would be pretty significant, but the Nest is not equal to a traditional programmable thermostat.

Nest can be controlled remotely from your phone, whether you’re home or on the go. Pair up with Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant and control the Nest with just your voice.

FarSight technology makes it easy to see the settings from up to 20′ away. And speaking of away… when you’re not home, the Nest can adjust to that as well, so you use energy when you need, and don’t waste it for times that you don’t.

Nest Thermostat E vs. 3rd Generation vs. 2nd Generation vs. 1st Generation

Below you’ll find a complete comparison of important specifications on the Nest thermostat E vs. 3rd generation vs. 2nd generation vs. 1st generation.

Look:

SpecificationsNest (3rd gen.)Nest Thermostat ENest (2nd gen.)Nest (1st gen.)
Smart Home thermostat - Nest LearningNest Thermostat E smart thermostatSmart Home thermostat - Nest LearningSmart Home thermostat - Nest Learning
ManufacturerNestNestNestNest
Model3rd GenerationThermostat E2nd Generation1st Generation
Release DateSeptember 1, 2015August 31, 2017October 2, 2012October 25, 2011
In ProductionYesYesYesDiscontinued
Length3.3"3.19"3.2"3.2"
Width3.3"3.19"3.2"3.2"
Depth from wall1.21"1.14"1.26"1.6"
Wifi2.4GHz, 5GHz b/g/n2.4 GHz b/g/n2.4 GHz b/g/n2.4 GHz b/g/n
Display Size2.08" diameter1.76" diameter1.75" diameter1.75" diameter
Resolution480x480 @ 229 ppi320x320 @ 182 ppi320x320320x320
TouchscreenNoNoNoNo
Temperature SensorsSold SeparatelySold SeparatelySold SeparatelySold Separately
Temperature SensorsYesYesYesYes
Humidity SensorsYesYesYesYes
Motion SensorsYesYesYesYes
Proximity SensorsYesYesYesYes
Ambient Light SensorYesYesYesYes
Voice ControlCompatible, but not includedCompatible, but not includedCompatible, but not includedCompatible, but not included
WeatherYesYesYesYes
Energy Savings (avg. determined by manuf)10-12% on heating; 15% on cooling10-12% on heating; 15% on cooling10-12% on heating; 15% on cooling10-12% on heating; 15% on cooling
Free Monthly ReportsYesYesYesYes
Returns30 days via Amazon. Varies by retailer30 days via Amazon. Varies by retailer30 days via Amazon. Varies by retailer30 days via Amazon. Varies by retailer
Warranty2 Year1 Year1 YearNA
PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck PriceCheck Price

Who Should Buy the Nest Learning Thermostat?

It has the familiar feel of a traditional adjustable thermostat, but with new smart features that make it one of the most popular smart thermostats on the market. The Nest Learning Thermostat is designed with easy setup and top-of-the-line features in mind.

I would recommend the Nest Learning Thermostat if you’re looking for the following features in a smart home thermostat: 

  • Want a programmable thermostat that you don’t have to program: The whole concept behind the Learning Thermostat is that you can teach the thermostat the settings that you like and it will take it from there.
  • Want a familiar feel: If full touchscreen feels a bit too futuristic to you, you’ll like the look of the Nest smart thermostats. They have an outer ring that rotates to adjust the temperature or scroll through menu or settings.
  • Want a simpler user interface: From the home display screen, there are minimal settings and details on the home screen. The display is simple, sleek, and to the point. The FarSight technology makes it easy to see exactly the numbers you care most about and forget the rest.

For more information on the Nest Learning Thermostat (3rd generation), check it out at Amazon.com.

For more information on the Nest E Thermostat, check it out on Amazon here.

An All-Time Favorite for a Reason
  • 95%
    Design - 95%
  • 97%
    Performance - 97%
  • 95%
    Quality - 95%
  • 95%
    Usability - 95%
  • 95%
    Value - 95%
95%

Summary

The Nest thermostat offers everything you’d want in a smart thermostat. Its design is intuitive and easy to use, it’s easy to install (took about 20 minutes), it’s packed with features that allow it to be completely on auto-pilot, and it can save most users money every month due to its efficiency features. I do wish it was compatible with the Samsung SmartThings hub and had built in voice control, but those are really the only disadvantages.

Why did the Nest thermostat score the way it did?

  • Design – Modern and sleek enclosure, easy to control via smartphone. Wheel design feels and functions great.
  • Performance – Absolutely packed with features that let you control every setting or allows the device to run on auto-pilot and learn itself.
  • Quality – Overall, very pleased with quality. I’ve had the Nest generation 2 in my personal home for a couple years. It’s just as good today as it was day 1.
  • Usability – Voice control (with standalone device), smartphone control, on device control. It’s got everything you would want. Lost 1 point vs. Ecobee4 since it doesn’t have built in voice control.
  • Value – Fairly typical price compared to other high-end smart thermostat. Feels fairly priced for what you get.
Derek Hales

Derek Hales

Editor-in-Chief

Derek Hales is the Editor-in-Chief and Founder of ModernCastle.com. He is a passionate perfectionist when it comes to testing and reviewing products for the home. When he is not testing new products, Derek enjoys golf, tennis, and PC gaming. Derek lives in Phoenix, Arizona, with his wife, Samantha, and poodle, Tibbers.